Hybrids are not sustainable and will never be sustainable as long as they are designed with small batteries that are overloaded, and with ICE engine as the primary drive. We have 7 severe cases: a Mercedes w205 with a burnt and cooked battery, a boiled VW GTE, 2 Kias with burnt and cooked batteries, a Porsche Panamera with a burnt and cooked battery, and 3 Toyota Priuses with burnt and cooked batteries. You are very brave, gentlemen, to drive either a new diesel or a hybrid in general. Besides being unreliable with very expensive failures, the savings are placebo and maintenance costs at 150k km can cost up to €20,000. A 2017 Kia Optima Plugin with only 160k km came in with a battery failure, hoping it was just a few cells, we called the owner in for diagnostics and repair. After disassembly and measurement, we found all cells to be inflated, cooked, and totally degraded. The system is air-cooled. The owner stated that the battery failure had started earlier while the vehicle was still under warranty, but the service center likely just erased the error after diagnosis and declared “everything is fine”. However, it is not fine, and on the third vehicle, by deceiving the owner, they erase the error via OBD to turn off the malfunction light and temporarily “solve the problem”. Classic KMAG warranty rape on a battery that should be subject to an automatic global recall as the swelling of cells is a “safety risk” and could potentially cause a fire if a cell breaches the battery case. A new battery costs about €17,000 to replace for a 9kWh battery. The cells are LG Chem, non-standard dimensions 17x24x0.6 with a capacity of 27Ah. The internal resistance of the cells is about 4mOhm (2 is actually for trash). Since it’s not just a couple of defective cells but the entire battery pack, repair is not possible. It’s not possible in that quantity because there are no new cells to replace it. The vehicle is theoretically trash at 160k km. Now you might wonder why? Because your mainstream media misinformed you with paid propaganda that EVs are bad, while hybrids and diesel are good. Every day social media is full of the same propaganda and demonizing headlines against EVs. In practice, it’s quite different, only the Nissan Leaf has an irreparable battery, while every hybrid is a pile of expensive trash at 200k. The only hybrid that would theoretically be sustainable is with at least a 40-50kWh battery, primary electric drive, and a generator that recharges, like the BMW REX system, everything else is just costing you more, not saving you money.
OEM Price Kia: €17,000. 150k km
Mercedes: €15,000 160k km
Porsche: €18,000 180k km
VW GTE: €12,000 180k km
EVC: not repairable, needs new battery design and production – €8,000-€16,000
Part number: 37503-A8510, 37506-E6610
Error: P0A7F, P1B96
Hallo,
ich habe ihren Beitrag mit Intresse gelesen. Ich hatte eine Discovery 300 e
dieser hatte im ersten Halbjahr keine Probleme außer Vibrationsgeräusche die beseitigt wurden. Dann ging es erst richtig los Steuergeräte, 2x Thermalmanagement und einen elektrischen Totalausfall. Zum Glück war das alles in der Garantie und ich hatte beim Händler eine Garantieverlängerung durch gesetzt die beim zweiten ausfall der Thermalmanagement gegriffen hat.
Den Rover habe ich am Lessing ende zurück gegeben. Zur Zeit fahre ich einen Kona facelift der jetzt die 60000 km überschritten hat und bei ca. 40000 km einen defekten Onbordlader hatte, an sonst leistet der Kona fehlerfrei seinen Dienst.
Mit freundlichen Grüßen
Klaus Weimar